The Motorola Atrix 4G Android phone is coming to AT&T. A recent review made a statement about the data download and upload speeds. Remember the Atrix is a “4G” phone: In comparison to other handsets we’ve tested on the network in the same spots, the Atrix 4G actually got lower speed rankings on both downstream and upstream tests. In general, we saw an average download speed of around 1.5 Mbps, while uploads were even worse at just about 0.15 Mbps. We did see download speeds spike occasionally into 2.2 Mbps territory, but that wasn’t the norm. During the testing, the phone had four or five bars, and was clearly displaying the HSPA+ icon.
The odd thing is that if you compare the device against the iPhone 4 on AT&T’s network — tested in exactly the same locations — you see much different results. On the iPhone, data speeds were consistently in the 2 or 3 Mbps range for downloads, and hovering around 1 Mbps for uploads.
Let’s not fool ourselves. AT&T rebranded their 3G network as 4G because they were the last network without a “4G” gimmick. These HSPA+ speeds aren’t anywhere near the advertised speed, and add the latency on top of that and it really doesn’t even matter what speed it is. Still though, you would hope that tacking on “4G” onto the name of the phone itself would at least beat a phone that is obviously showing a “3G” symbol at the top.
Unfortunately, the iPhone 5 is
hinting at 3G for at least one more year. Let’s take bets now, LTE iPhone 6 anyone?